|
|
Device and price | Number and types of devices supported | Interface | Ease of Use (outside of thermd) |
Notes | Rating |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
QK145 $ $24.49 (kit) Price includes one DS18S20 sensor |
Up to 4 temperature sensors connected to individual 3-pin plugs | 2400 baud DB-9 Serial | Extremely easy | Temperature data streams out serial line—no polling required. QK145 does not need a power supply (it derives power from the RS-232 line). This is a kit—you must build it yourself. | Best buy for the price-conscious (if all you need is temperature monitoring and nothing else). |
DS9097 and DS9490 $ $28 |
"Many" 1-wire devices (all 1-wire devices are supported), connected with an RJ12 jack. | 9600 baud DB-9 Serial (DS9097) or USB (DS9490) | Variable | Extremely flexible, can address every 1-wire device made. This is simply a serial line (or USB) to 1-wire converter. You must write (or obtain) driver software to communicate with the bus. When used with owfs and/or owhttpd. accessing devices is very easy. | |
VK011 $ $39.95 Price includes one DS18S20 sensor |
Up to 4 temperature sensors connected to individual screw terminals. | 9600 baud DB-9 Serial | Extremely easy | Temperature data streams out serial line—no polling; Hi-lo values available via setup menu. VK011 power supply is optional (it can derive power from the RS-232 line). | |
6 Channel Master Hub $ $52.25 |
"Many" 1-wire devices on each of the 6 1-wire busses (all 1-wire devices are supported), connected with an RJ12 jack per bus. | 9600 baud DB-9 Serial | Variable | Extremely flexible, can address every 1-wire device made. This is simply a multi-channel serial line to 1-wire converter. You must write (or obtain) driver software to communicate with the bus. When used with owfs and/or owhttpd. accessing devices is very easy. | Best buy for an experienced Linux user with a need for a wide variety of sensors |
TEMP08 $ $75–$125 Prices are with or without on-board humidity sensor |
Up to 60 temperature, humidity, lightning, barometer, wind, and/or rain sensors on a single powered bus (connected on a single RJ12 jack or screw terminals). | 9600 baud DB-9 Serial | Relatively easy—command set is a little awkward, but not difficult. Firmware can be upgraded by replacing the PLC chip | Devices can be automatically polled at user-selectable intervals. Devices which are not known to the TEMP08 firmware are completely unsupported—but most environmental sensors are supported, check user's manual; can be expanded to include relay output and opto-isolated input with the an additional Midon Design device, the 1WIO. | |
LOG08 $$ $125–$150 Prices are with or without on-board humidity sensor |
Up to 60 temperature, humidity, lightning, barometer, wind, and/or rain sensors on a single powered bus (connected on a single RJ12 jack or screw terminals). | 9600 baud DB-9 Serial | Relatively easy—command set is a little awkward, but not difficult. Firmware can be upgraded by replacing the PLC chip | Devices can be automatically polled at user-selectable intervals; Some sensors (temperature, humidity, barometer) can also be logged by the LOG08 for later reporting (can be acquired in time-stamped CSV format). Devices which are not "known" to the LOG08 firmware are completely unsupported—but most environmental sensors are supported, check user's manual. | Best buy for logging data with no external programming |
HA7Net $$ $155.95 |
The HA7Net supports all1-wire devices with 3 independent 1-wire busses, each with jumperable built-in power and 150 ohm pull-up resistor. It is possible to have 100 devices on each bus, with total wire runs of up to 2000 feet. Sensors are connected via an RJ-12 jack per bus. | Ethernet | Relatively easy—separate URLs to address each type of sensor; once you figure them out, can easily program a data collection system. Firmware can be updated via web interface. | Web access for administration, configuration, and sensor reading. Supports HTTP and HTTPS protocols (the only device on this chart that does so); Telnet connection for debugging. Device addresses must be known to be used (but the HA7Net has a discovery mode). Can be panel mounted or on DIN rails. Extremely flexible unit, can address every 1-wire device made. Built-in firmware support for temperature, humidity, barometric pressure, LED display, digital and analog sensors, PIO devices, etc; direct firmware access to 1-wire bus for devices not contemplated or provided by the manufacturer. | #1 Best overall value, feature set, and flexibility (requires some programming skill for advanced use). |
Poseidon and Damocles
$$$ €128–€500 Prices vary depending on model, optional GSM feature and number of sensors |
Units can handle up to 41 external sensors, 24 binary inputs, and/or 16 relay controlled outputs. HWgroup in the Czech Republic makes a wide variety of 1-wire and RS-485 industrial sensors, including temperature (including a unique 19" rack-mount version), humidity, flood, smoke, combustible gas, power, door-contact, etc.) | Ethernet | Very easy. Firmware can also be updated easily. | Web interface for sensor readings; devices also support SNMP, Modbus, SMTP, GSM SMS, and XML (some support all of these. The only device in this list with integrated relays for turning devices on and off. Also the only devices with built-in GSM modem support and RS-485 industrial sensors (more robust communication than 1-wire) | Excellent, well built units. Do not be scared off by the fact that they are in the Czech Republic - these are reliable units from a reliable company! |
EM1 $$$ $299 |
The EM1 supports temperature, humidity, and wetness sensors (up to 4 of each type). Sensors are connected via individual screw terminals. | Ethernet (for reading sensors) and 9600 baud DB-25 Serial (for configuration). | Easy. Serial port must be used to configure device; once configured, accessing data is simple (in a variety of formats). | Web interface provides human-readable and machine parsable formats; also supports SNMP reading of sensors. Devices are reported according to which port they are wired, reports can feature user-selectable names. | |
TemPageR $$$ $245–$295 Prices includes one internal and one external temperature sensor, alert software and 1 year maintenance contract |
Up to 4 temperature sensors (1 internal, 3 external connected individual RJ11 jacks). | Ethernet | Very easy. Firmware can be updated via a Windows-based discovery program or via TFTP. | Web interface for temperature readings (very nice graphical display); over and under-temperature alarms directly supported; pager/SMS support built in; also supports SNMP reading of sensors and SNMP traps. Devices are reported according to which port they are wired, reports can feature user-selectable names. 1-wire Temperature/Humidity devices are wired using non-standard RJ11 configuration. TemPageR can be optionally rack mounted in a 1U bracket. | |
Newport and Omega iServer $$$ $299–$395+ Prices do not include sensors |
Temperature, Humidity, Pressure (etc.) sensors, depending on model | Ethernet | Very easy. | Has a Java-based web-browser interface, as well as a port reserved for instrument readings for non-web use; over and under-threshold alarms directly supported; High-quality industrial sensors which can be supplied with NIST Traceable Calibration Certificates. Sensors are typically connected using DIN screw-type connectors, some use industry standard connectors. Most units can be mounted on DIN rails. | Excellent units for industrial quality environments. |
Proliphix
IP-enabled thermostats $$$ $254–$575 Prices vary depending on model, number of external sensors, and powering requirements |
Up to 3 temperature sensors (1 internal, 2 external) and one humidity sensor via screw terminals and standard thermostat wiring. | Ethernet | Very easy. Web interface includes the ability to program the thermostat remotely (ideal for commercial units or vacation homes). | Web interface for temperature readings and programming the thermostat; over and under-temperature alarms directly supported; manual fallbacks. Can also monitor the state of the furnace (heating, cooling, idle, etc). | The only IP-enabled thermostats that I know of. |
Veris line of
Enercept Networked Power Meters
$$$ $??? Prices vary depending on model |
One circuit, but can measure 1, 2, or 3-phase power, voltage, KW, KWh, power factor, etc. | Modbus | Easy (once you understand ModBus) | No web interface, but an extern program is provided for ease of use. | Good for industrial power monitoring of specific circuits, also good for monitoring Solar Photovoltaic (PV) power production. |
RacSense and Weather Goose $$$$ $199–$639 |
All RacSense and Weather Goose units support a wide variety of sensors
(see the websites for details). Most external sensors are connected via RJ11
jacks and busses, switch sensors are connected via screw terminals.
MiniGoose ($199) has one internal temperature sensor and supports up to 16 remote sensors. WeatherGoose ($399) has internal temperature, humidity, air flow, light level, and sound level sensors, plus three analog input ports. An internal 5 port serial port hub makes adding remote sensors easy. Also supports web cameras as part of the interface. SuperGoose ($499) is the same as the WeatherGoose plus a built-in LCD display and audio alarm for machine room use. PowerGoose ($639) is similar to the WeatherGoose with the addition of built-in power monitoring (voltage, current, power-factor) and 10-plug (non-switched) outlet strip in the back. RacSense ($depends) provides a variety of power and environmental monitoring systems - see the websites for more details. |
Ethernet | Very easy | Web interface for temperature readings (nice graphical display); Over and under-temperature alarms directly supported; also supports SNMP reading of sensors and SNMP traps. Devices are reported according to 1-wire ID, reports can feature user-selectable names. | Best systems for plug-and-play machine room monitoring with no external software support required. |
Room Alert $$$$ $395–$995 Prices include sensors (type and number vary by model and are outlined to the right), alert software and 1 year maintenance contract |
All Room Alert units support temperature, humidity, and dry-contact
"switch" sensors. External temperature and humidity sensor are connected
via individual RJ11 jacks, switch sensors are connected via screw terminals.
The Room Alert 7E ($395-445) supports 1 internal temperature sensor (included), up to 3 external temperature sensors (1 is included), and up to 3 switch sensors (an external main power sensor is included). The Room Alert 11E ($445-545) supports up to 3 external temperature or temperature/humidity sensors (one of each is included), and up to 8 switch sensors (an external main power sensor is included). The Room Alert 26W ($995) supports 1 internal temperature sensor (included), 1 flood sensor (included - just add cable), a built-in main power sensor, up to 6 external temperature or temperature/humidity sensors (one temperature sensor is included), and up to 16 switch sensors (one room entry sensor is included). It also features a built-in UPS and built-in wireless sensor hub capability. | Ethernet | Easy. Firmware can be updated via a Windows-based discovery program or via TFTP. | Web interface for temperature readings (very nice graphical display); Over and under-temperature alarms directly supported; pager/SMS support built in; also supports SNMP reading of sensors and SNMP traps. Devices are reported according to which port they are wired, reports can feature user-selectable names. 1-wire Temperature/Humidity devices are wired using non-standard RJ11 configuration. Room Alerts can be optionally rack mounted in a 1U bracket. | |
Enersure $$$$ Contact Trendpoint A full system includes a processor board, one to four data collection boards, a 220VAC power transformer and up to 22 split-core current transformers per data collection board (for a total of up to 88 circuits) |
The Enersure is strictly a power monitoring system. For each circuit, you can examine voltage, current, power factor, wattage, and KWh used. | RS-232 or RS-485 Serial, Ethernet or 802.11 WiFi | Non-trivial. Device communicates using RTU ModBus protocol (but support for it is fully integrated within thermd). | All communication to the device is through the EnerSure Windows- or Linux-based application, or through ModBus commands (only one application can communicate with the device at a time). Current transformers are conneected via screw terminals, but a licensed electrician must be used to add them to your circuit-breaker box. This system is designed for enterprise use, and not for the casual home hobbyist. | If you want to monitor power consumption, this unit is the best |